Skip to content

Movie Review: “Hershey”

hershey mp“Hershey”

By Bob Garver

In many ways, “Hershey” is the movie event of 2026, at least in my hometown in Central Pennsylvania. No amount of Odysseys, Brand New Days, or Doomsdays can compare to a biopic of the man who put a whole community on the map – largely under his own name. He’s even the namesake of my full-time employer all the way up in New York City (Hershey’s Chocolate World Times Square). Everybody locally is hoping that this movie does Hershey – the man, the brand, and the town – justice. I’m pleased to report that it does. It might not be a very “biting” biopic, much like how one is not supposed to bite too much into Hershey’s Chocolate, but it gets the job done of making the world seem like a better place for having had Milton and Catherine Hershey in it.

Hershey (played by James Kelly as a child and Finn Wittrock as an adult) grows up the poor child of stern-but-loving Fanny Snavely (Francesca Faridany) and irresponsible dreamer Henry Hershey (Alan Ruck). He wants to pursue whimsical ambitions and indulge his sweet tooth, but there’s work to be done, especially following the death of his sister and departure of his father. He’s fortunate enough to find a job with Joseph R. Royer (Richard Kind), a – yes – “kind”-ly candymaker who understands that the person passing out samples is the coolest person in the store. Royer gives Hershey unprecedented encouragement, even when he fails, which proves to be a lot.

Hershey tries and fails to open his own candy businesses in Lancaster, New Orleans, Chicago, Denver, and New York, never giving up and always learning how to improve along the way. It’s on a second pass at Lancaster, with old friend “Lebbie” Lebkicher (Michael Moreland Milligan) handling the business side of things, that he begins to – yes – “taste” success with his caramel company. He wants to take things even further and open the country’s first dedicated chocolate factory with a whole town of loyal employees. Can he make his dream a reality, or will the name of a nearby town forever remain Derry Church?

It’s around this time that he meets Catherine “Kitty” Sweeney (Alexandra Daddario), who isn’t like other women because she focuses more on being kind to children than finding a husband. This, ironically, makes her the perfect wife in Hershey’s eyes. The two fall madly in love, marry, and hope to have children, but it is not to be. This – yes – “bittersweet” storyline of course leads to the Milton Hershey School and Hershey Trust. Other key moments in the couple’s relationship include the accidental creation of the winning chocolate formula, the accidental creation of the Hershey’s Kiss, and the lifesaving decision to leave a tour of Europe early and not head back to America on a certain doomed ocean liner.

“Hershey” is perfectly agreeable, touching, and delicious-looking in the right parts. I can’t say this is the kind of movie that makes me see Milton Hershey any differently as a historical figure, if only because I’ve had the man’s story continually imparted onto me for the last forty years. About the only thing I didn’t expect in the movie was that Don Papson, former General Manager of Hershey’s Chocolate World (in Hershey) and Executive Director of the M.S. Hershey Foundation, is a full-fledged producer. More directly than Milton Hershey, I have him to thank for my job in New York. I’m too close to the film to feel appropriate reducing it to a simple letter grade, but I’ll say this: much like Hershey’s Chocolate itself, the film is cheesy, but awesome.

“Hershey” opens wide on Wednesday, November 25. The film is rated PG for some thematic elements and brief language. Its running time is 110 minutes.

Contact Bob Garver at [email protected].

Leave a Comment