Movie Review: “Ebenezer”
“Ebenezer”
By Bob Garver
In the weeks leading up to “Ebenezer,” I couldn’t decide if I should be excited for the latest adaptation of Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol.” I feel compelled to express my prospective excitement by invoking another Dickens work, “A Tale of Two Cities”: It could be the best of films, it could be the worst of films.
It could be the best of films because it is directed by Ti West, the filmmaker behind the “X” horror trilogy, which included the powerful one-two punch of “X” and “Pearl” in 2022. Readers who say I never put any movies on the A-tier in my reviews should know that I would have given “Pearl” an A- grade had the film done well enough to warrant an official review. No doubt West could cook up some nice horror touches for a film based on a book whose very first line mentions a death. I’m not above liking family-friendly adaptations of the work (Disney animation and The Muppets being my favorites), but if this one wants to emphasize the dark, it’s got the right person to make it dark.
Then again, it could also be the worst of films because Johnny Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge. The last 10-20 years have not been kind to Depp. I’ll leave his offscreen life out of the equation and say that his choice of roles has indicated a pattern of complacency. He’s seemingly split his time between running his Jack Sparrow character into the ground and playing numerous, increasingly-indistinguishable pale-skinned weirdos for Tim Burton. A character as twisted as Scrooge is right up Depp’s alley, but that’s exactly why it’s wrong for him, because he has so many others just like it. Also, all the advertising has given away that he’s just recycling his Jack Sparrow voice for this role.
For those not familiar with the source material, the story follows Christmas-hating moneylender Scrooge as he is haunted on Christmas Eve, first by the ghost of his late business partner Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen), who tells him a terrible fate awaits him if he doesn’t change his selfish ways, then by the spirits of Christmases Past (Andrea Riseborough), Present (Trammell Tillman), and Yet to Come (Robert Strange). In so being haunted, Scrooge learns that he needs to be nicer to people in his life that love Christmas, like his nephew Fred (Sam Claflin) and underpaid clerk Bob Cratchet (Rupert Grint). Will he learn his lesson in time to save Cratchet’s sickly son, Tiny Tim (Freddy Lee-Grey)?
The good news is that I was right about West and his horror touches. The ghosts are indeed scary, with Past and Present having such disturbing…presences that Yet to Come, the one that is “supposed” to be the scary one, is probably the least unnerving of the three. Jump scares are effective and occasional violent episodes will remind viewers that Victorian England is not the merriest of settings. I’ll even deliver another piece of good news: Depp isn’t that bad. The Jack Sparrow-ness of the performance is distracting at first, but once you warm up to it, you’ll see that he’s bringing complex emotion to the role.
So if West is as good as expected, and Depp is better than expected, then why am I not recommending “Ebenezer”? The answer is that no matter how much West does to make the film his own, there is no escaping the sheer expectedness (and not “Great” expectedness, just expectedness) of “A Christmas Carol.” The Internet Movie Database recognizes 273 such adaptations for film and television, not to mention stage and literary versions. I’ve been beaten over the head so many times by this property that anytime the dialogue in this movie went in a familiar direction, I couldn’t help but tune out. And because the movie took nearly two hours to get through a story that’s been done to death, that meant a lot of tuning out. West and Depp almost pulled off this unsolicited collaboration, but not quite.
Grade: C
“Ebenezer” is rated PG-13 for frightening material. Its running time is 116 minutes.
Contact Bob Garver at [email protected].
